Results 1 to 40 of 743

Thread: [Serious]Why are you not a believer of the existence of God

Threaded View

  1. #11
    New Member
    Join Date
    Apr 2005
    Posts
    4

    Re: [Serious]Why are you not a believer of the existence of God

    Quote Originally Posted by Lord Orwell View Post
    agnostics... You can't have it every way. Either one religion is right or none of them are or all of them are.
    1. If one is right, you are wrong by not choosing that one.
    2. If none of them are, you are wrong because you haven't realized they are all wrong.
    3. If all of them are, you are wrong my not deciding on one of them.

    In any case, you haven't made a decision and that makes you wishy-washy.
    I can't decide if you're serious or just like to argue for the sake of it....

    "1. If one is right, you are wrong by not choosing that one."

    Nope. If in your not pursuaded by any given religion, it is not reasonable to adopt it's beliefs. You may choose to do so on Faith. You cant be morally right or wrong if you are objective. You may come to the wrong conclusion, but nobody can question your honesty.

    "2. If none of them are, you are wrong because you haven't realized they are all wrong."

    Same as "1"

    "3. If all of them are, you are wrong my not deciding on one of them."

    Same as "1". But in addition.... How can all of them be right? Even if you limit yourself to all christian-based religions, there are glaring differences between them. For example, the Holy Trinity concept.

    If you are a parent of 2 or more children, and I asked you which one you loved the most, would it be wishy-washy to conclude you loved them all the same? If one of them spilled coffee on your keyboard and none of them admitted doing it, would it be possible you couldn't tell who the culprit was and not punish any of them. Or would you force yourself to pick one of them on the slightest evidence and punish the one you chose?

    Please think about your comments before posting them. You might be right about your religious beliefs, but your arguments are so poorly thought out, you may pursuade other posters to become atheist or agnostic.
    Last edited by MassSpec; Feb 8th, 2010 at 09:10 AM.

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •  



Click Here to Expand Forum to Full Width