I'm also getting married soon (April). We have booked plans to go to Bermuda (2 hours from Newark, NJ). The price wasn't that bad either. Some places are all-inclusive too.
My fiance likes to get a tan while I'll go golfing. They say that guys shouldn't bring clubs on your honeymoon, but my fiance insists that I bring them! We don't know when we'll get back there again.