Weird icon behavior....

[Flavor Flav]

I made an icon for my program and I used http://www.icoconverter.com/ to convert my icon into a .ico file so I could use it in my program. I built the program and I got the program from my release folder and I put it on my desktop and the icon looks like this

But, if I rename the file something like "afsadgubdgu" then the icon changes to the proper icon. HOWEVER, if I rename the program to the original name. the icon goes back to looking like this


I AM SO CONFUSED!