I think I just figured this out. Stumbled across a link on another page which then lead to another link, then the answer

Looks like I need to use the following if I do not know the name of the Shape:

Code:
ActiveSheet.Shapes(1).Select
This way, it will always take the first shape it comes into contact with and it doesn't matter if the name changes.

FYI to anyone else who needs to figure this out. Hope this helps.