[2005] Correct way of dealing with multiple options

In my program I need to change the available controls based on what the user does, so I have three different things to determine control visibility and play event.

for the play event here is a sample of what happens when a user clicks on play:

Code:

---

Private Sub BtnPlay_Click(ByVal sender As System.Object, ByVal e As System.EventArgs) Handles BtnPlay.Click, StationsList.DoubleClick, FavoritesList.DoubleClick

        If My.Settings.ShowFavorites = True Then
            If My.Settings.PlayType = True Then
                If (Player1.playState = WMPPlayState.wmppsPlaying) Then
                    If Player1.currentMedia.sourceURL = FavoritesList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value Then
                        Player1.Ctlcontrols.pause()
                    Else
                        Player1.URL = FavoritesList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value
                    End If
                Else
                    Player1.URL = FavoritesList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value
                End If
            Else
                If (Player1.playState = WMPPlayState.wmppsPlaying) Then
                    Player1.Ctlcontrols.pause()
                Else
                    Player1.Ctlcontrols.play()
                End If
            End If
        Else

        End If
        If My.Settings.PlayType = True Then
            If (Player1.playState = WMPPlayState.wmppsPlaying) Then
                If Player1.currentMedia.sourceURL = StationsList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value Then
                    Player1.Ctlcontrols.pause()
                Else
                    Player1.URL = StationsList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value
                End If
            Else
                Player1.URL = StationsList.CurrentRow.Cells(1).Value
            End If
        Else
            If (Player1.playState = WMPPlayState.wmppsPlaying) Then
                Player1.Ctlcontrols.pause()
            Else
                Player1.Ctlcontrols.play()
            End If
        End If
    End Sub

---

I can't figure out how to handle this with a case statement unless I define each state individually, and if I was how would I? Is there some better way?

Trying to read this code is very hard and it looks a little like spaghetti code. Maybe Fettucini code.

Does what you have work?

No it doesn't, well it partly works, it's too confusing to figure out what I'm doing wrong. I'm not familiar with all the new .net oop styles and I think this could work better if I create a "playtype" class where I handle each option individually. But I'm not sure exactly how to do it (not how to make a class, but handle each situation).

Maybe an interface?

You may find that using a Select Case statement is easier to manage if you have tons of if/elseif/else statements...