[RESOLVED] Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Printable View

Dec 4th, 2005, 05:03 PM
iPrank

[RESOLVED] Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Sorry if it has been already answered. I'm new here (only 29 posts so far).

So far I've got only 7 reputations. (Default 5 + 2).
But I actually recived 3 'Approve' comments. One of them was from a member who is under 20 posts himself.
So, I guess vBulletin didn't added any point for his approval.

This brings a question,

If new members can't give reputation points (just 2-3 days ago I wasn't able to), doesn't it discourages 'some' members to post in his/her thread ?

What if the new-member is new in VB too ? He/she can't answer other peoples threads even if he/she is willing to help. (I'm with VB6 for almost 1 year, but still some of the threads are way over my brain.)
Dec 4th, 2005, 05:07 PM
yitzle

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Reputation is not there to get people to post. The forum is for those who want to help and get help. The giving is not intended to be for reward.
I just realized I'm not in the top 500 posters like I thought I'd be. I'm over 2000 from the top!
Dec 4th, 2005, 05:20 PM
iPrank

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by yitzle

Reputation is not there to get people to post. The forum is for those who want to help and get help. The giving is not intended to be for reward.
I just realized I'm not in the top 500 posters like I thought I'd be. I'm over 2000 from the top!

Sorry. I guess I wasn't able to explain my 'whole' point. (Please excuse my poor English.)

That was one part of the story - for members who could give rep points.

Please think my position when I was under 20 posts.

I know my 'Titlebar Button' related thread in API forum isn't a very common one. If somebody solved my problem, when I was under 20 post, I had no way to show him/her my gratitude. (except verbal ofcourse)

Just think how should I (or any new member) feel ?
Dec 4th, 2005, 05:22 PM
yitzle

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

That a thank you is all you have to offer and it must suffice. Most members can offer no more than you, and no more than that could possiblby be expected of you. A verbal thank you is more than the helper wants. S/her posted to help you and for no other reason.
Dec 4th, 2005, 05:25 PM
iPrank

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

THANK YOU !

:D:D:D:D:D
Dec 4th, 2005, 06:03 PM
yitzle

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Wow! You're very welcome! :)
Dec 5th, 2005, 11:58 AM
brad jones

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by yitzle

A verbal thank you is more than the helper wants. S/her posted to help you and for no other reason.

This verbal thank you can also be done with the reputation "rate this post" feature. Even though no points are given, a "thank you" or a "that really helped" is appreciated. I'd say the text provided in the reputations is generally more appreciated than the points.

Brad!
Dec 5th, 2005, 12:03 PM
yitzle

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

I wasn't aware rating posts including text!
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:15 PM
iPrank

Another question

Quote:

Originally Posted by yitzle

I wasn't aware rating posts including text!

Yes, there is a small textbox in the reputation pop-up window.

Another question :

I have given reputation to someone in other's thread. Will he/she receive my message ?
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:19 PM
dglienna

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Yes. It is best to include your name in that textbox, so that the person getting the points knows that they came from you. I always use my name with leaving points.
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:21 PM
Harsh Gupta

Re: Another question

Quote:

Originally Posted by iPrank

Yes, there is a small textbox in the reputation pop-up window.

Another question :

I have given reputation to someone in other's thread. Will he/she receive my message ?

yes from now on. a member needs atleast 20 posts and 5 rep points to be able to add rep. you can see the post by Penagate on reputations and related topics in my signature. in the Rate link.
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:24 PM
iPrank

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

http://www.vbforums.com/showpost.php...60&postcount=5
;) ;)
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:34 PM
Harsh Gupta

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by iPrank

http://www.vbforums.com/showpost.php...60&postcount=5
;) ;)

:ehh: what was that??
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:40 PM
iPrank

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

It's a post titled "Dhanyabaad".
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:44 PM
Harsh Gupta

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by iPrank

It's a post titled "Dhanyabaad".

hey do you know Hindi? where are you from?

BTW, what DG wanted to say that when you want to add rep to somebody's post, mention your name in the textbox below the option buttons. it's just about great gesture. even i mention my name when i rate posts.

PS - it's DHANYAVAAD ;)
Dec 5th, 2005, 01:51 PM
iPrank

Re: Reputation - Is it good for new members ?

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harsh Gupta

hey do you know Hindi?

Can't speak well, but can read/write a little.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harsh Gupta

where are you from?
PS - it's DHANYAVAAD ;)

In where I'm, it is DHANYABAAD ;)

Quote:

Originally Posted by Harsh Gupta

BTW, what DG wanted to say that when you want to add rep to somebody's post, mention your name in the textbox below the option buttons. it's just about great gesture. even i mention my name when i rate posts.

Ya. I've already made that mistake. Thought that vBulletin autometically adds my nick.