Contridictions in the Quran?

[kovan]

if you want to make same arguements about the quran as i am making about the bible

go to these sites
study them
come up with some contridictions

http://www.beconvinced.com
http://www.islaam.com
http://www.islam.org
http://www.jannaah.com

the ONLY reason i am posting this information is
i want someone to make a claim there is contridiction in the quran, because i believe in it and if i find a contridiction in it, it will HELP ME OUT A LOT

thank you

[Gen-X]

This isn't a contradiction but a common fallacy of most ancient religious documents.


222. And they ask you about menstruation. Say: It is a discomfort; therefore keep aloof from the women during the menstrual discharge and do not go near them until they have become clean; then when they have cleansed themselves, go in to them as Allah has commanded you; surely Allah loves those who turn much (to Him), and He loves those who purify themselves.


Why is it that all religions consider a woman having her monthly cycle to be "unclean"?

It is proof they completely misunderstand the whole process of normal bodily functions.

[Gen-X]

Again not a contradiction but something of interest on your "Science in the Qu'ran".


, "The heaven, We have built it with power. Verily. We are expanding it."


This was listed as being evidence the Qu'ran shows that the universe is expanding.

I have to question the use of the word "WE". That makes it sound as if the lowly little people believe they themselves are causing the universe to expand... Not very scientific and proof that people have read into it what they wanted to AFTER the fact so that it fits nicely.

This is common practice with Christians... Find something in the Bible that can be roughly twisted or warped to fit a real world instance and provide an explaination of how it fits.

[kovan]

i will bring you more information on that as i find it

[kovan]

yes its unclean, PHYSICALLY
you might think that it means women are dirty in every way spiritually and physically

would you have sex with a women during that period?

[kovan]

doesnt the big bang theory say the universe is expanding?
so isn't that what the quran says?

[Gen-X]

1. Unclean

Actually woman are NOT unclean during that time. The fluid acts as a protective layer and is nutrient rich, the fact that the protective bacteria can cause some problems for other people doesn't make it "unclean".

Is a person unclean for urinating?

2. Expansion

*sigh*

Listen to what I said...

Its the use of the word WE, as if to indicate the PEOPLE are responsible for the universe expanding.

If you read that quote it is quite obvious they mean the "heavens"... NOT the universe.. that someone made the assumption 1 means the other is not valid. Secondly, expanding also means in the sense of the people going out INTO it not that it happens itself.


But like I said before... you wouldn't see the contradiction or the error in any of it because you can't see it :(

[kovan]

Quran is word of God
so when it says WE
gawd is saying we
refering to himself and angels